So Payscale has a new compensation best practices report out. It’s a pretty comprehensive summary of what companies are doing in the market from a comp best practice standpoint, touching on more or less every pay related topic under the sun (the survey even breaks its data out by company size). You can read the whole thing here,1 but today I want to talk about one particular component of the survey.
Bonuses (specifically bonus types).
Take a look at the chart below (As stated above, you can get this chart – and the whole study – from the free Payscale survey here):
A few interesting points:
1. Individual incentive bonuses are pretty much standard once one reaches a certain level professionally, but did anyone expect that 2/3rds of even small companies give them out?
I really wanted to find some place to stick this picture. Image credit: <www.cardwisdom.com>
2. Conversely, I’m shocked that the hiring/sign on bonus number is so small even among large companies. More or less everyone I know received a hiring bonus out of school (and they signed with a fairly significant medley of fortune 500 companies). This of course just goes to show that anecdotal evidence is just that. It’s always good to have comprehensive data sets.
3. I’m pleasantly surprised to see that a quarter or more of employers at all size levels are giving team incentive bonuses. The workplace is becoming a more and more collaborative place over time, and organizational success is driven by talented groups far more often than rock-star individual contributors. Don’t get me wrong – individual incentive bonuses are of course great as well 2 – but if there is some extra money in the coffers team incentive bonuses are a fantastic tool to build employee engagement and increase performance.
4. I think retention bonuses are generally ineffective, and am also not surprised to see the largest companies pay them out twice as much as anyone else.
I can’t believe this image actually exists. Image Credit: <www.cafepress.com>
Essentially, there are three types of retention bonuses.
A. The “We know you’re unhappy here, but please don’t leave us! We have lousy succession planning and no one else can do your job so we’d rather have you here and miserable than have to figure out how to run this place without you!” bonus. This is a terrible bonus to give out, and if your company does then it’s doing it wrong.
B. The “We know you’re eventually leaving (or getting laid off), but we’re in the middle of this merger/acquisition/closing and we need you here while we get through this thing.” bonus. This is a perfectly acceptable bonus to give. Someone has to be there for the end, and those someones will probably have to delay their job searches a bit to be there for said end (because most employers don’t generally want to extend offers of employment with start dates several months into the future unless it’s for a college hire or an executive in a key role with a phased out retirement).
C. Finally, there is the “We’ve been underpaying you for a long time, you’ve figured it out and are unhappy, and we don’t want to lose you so we’re making it right.” bonus. My thoughts on this one? If the employee had to complain about his or her pay before anything was done about it then it’s probably too late. 3 But good on the employer for finally making things right, I guess?
5. Spot bonuses are wonderful, and I’m thrilled that 40+ percent of companies are giving them. One of my professional mentors once pointed out to me that frequent, small raises are better than annual large ones for employee morale 4, and in my opinion the spot bonus is the ultimate application of this philosophy.
A slap on the back and verbal accolades are always wonderful to receive, but nothing says thanks for a job well done quite like an unexpected cash bonus for a job well done (and besides, if a company starts giving money away all year there is no rule that says the merit budget has to stay as large as it was before).
“Thank You Bucks” look just like regular bucks – which are of course beautiful. Image Credit: <blog.jobthread.com>
A friend of mine (also in compensation) recently recounted the story to me of a spot bonus program at her company called “Thank You Bucks”. Basically, every manager has a certain amount of cash in their quarterly budget earmarked to give to employees who demonstrate exceptional performance.
If an employee completes a project quickly (and with strong results), exceeds expectations on a difficult project, improves the work environment in “X/Y/Z” way etc. then they can earn “Thank You Bucks” at any time during the quarter – money that shows up in the next paycheck.
Setting aside the risk of nepotism and/or corruption here, this is a fantastic idea. If I’m ever CHRO/SVP of HR I am 1,000% implementing something like “Thank You Bucks”.
…Anyway, that’s it for now. I kind of want to talk about the “other” bonus section listed on the chart, 5 but it’s getting late.
As always, please share your thoughts below.
If you have questions about something you’ve read here (or simply want to connect) you can reach me at any of the following addresses:
SomethingDifferentHR@gmail.com OR firstname.lastname@example.org